|
Extracts from the Interim
Psychiatric Evaluation of the Menai
The Brief:
As the notorious Topless Procession case has demonstrated,
the Menai ethnic group manifests an insular clannishness and
resistance to modernity. Is this a symptom of an underlying
psychiatric condition afflicting the entire tribe? Are those
traits likely to spread to Nigeria’s 500 other ethnic groups?
Do they threaten Nigerian nationalism? Is this condition treatable,
and if so, by what means?
The Subject:
The Menai ethnic group is a minor, endangered tribe
whose global population numbers, at the date of this interim
report, less than five hundred adults living in two hundred
households. 95% of all known Menai live in Kreektown, an impoverished
village on the Agui Creek in Nigerdelta State. Although the
only known instance of public nudity among the Menai was the
Topless Procession case, they are pathologically incapable of
adapting to city life, and are victims of a tribe-wide indoctrination
that prevents them from emigrating from Kreektown. They address
themselves as Menai, call their language Menai and (although
apparently of average intelligence) stubbornly speak Menai to
the exclusion of official Nigerian languages in their village
square…
Chief (Dr.) Ehi A. Fowaka
J.P. F.R.C.Psych. W.A.C.S. M.B.B.S. F.M.C.(Psych) F.W.A.C.P.
Ubesie | January, 19th 1994
I was at dinner that evening at The Great, Ubesie,
when the character called Jonszer arrived. My chief regret for taking
this assignment is my new familiarity with souls like Jonszer. He
was halfway across the restaurant, filthy, wild-eyed and pungent,
when I saw him. Fortunately the headwaiter, an elderly soul from
my town (smart fellow, I knew his godmother, would have done well
if he got his 4 GCEs) was just serving my food. I spoke to him with
my eyes (really sharp fellow, that headwaiter, doesn‘t miss a trick)
and he intercepted Jonszer two yards from me, and took him outside.
I then made quick work of my pounded yam. Apart from the bills for
my daughter’s school fees at Loyola Jesuit College, nothing brings
tears to my eyes like a fresh fillet of catfish steaming and trembling
in a hot plate of egusi soup. I had one such on my plate, and I
ate it with many prayers of thanksgiving to the munificent God that
watches over Ehi Fowaka.
Then I went out to meet Jonszer. This is what I
am wearing today: a white linen top and bottom, one of a dozen I
ordered at the start of Mr. President’s assignment. It is a light
but dignified outfit, perfect for getting around, especially in
these wretched parts where efficient air conditioners are few and
far between. He was quaffing his beer when I came out. That chief
waiter! He is cunning at things like that. He knows the best way
to keep someone like Jonszer engaged for a while.
‘Yes?’ I asked.
When he saw me he put his bottle to his mouth and
gobbled efficiently, putting it down when it was empty. He wiped
his mouth with the back of a hand. He came close to whisper. I didn’t
see the burp coming. He tried to suppress it but it only came out
more violently in my face. ‘You come, now.’ He did not mean to be
rude, or imperious. His English was careful and instrumental. Like
all Menai, it was very much a second language for him, spoken only
when the other person couldn’t be forced to speak Menai. He turned
to go.
There were five or six good reasons not to follow
the drunk and drug addict. Yet, Kreektown’s only hotel was a major
apology. Ears like Jonszer allow me to stay in the relative
comfort of The Great, Ubesie (the appalling name alone was enough
to take my business elsewhere, but my regular hotels were full),
while doing excellent fieldwork in Kreektown. I wanted to ask more
questions, but we were attracting attention. This is not the sort
of riffraff you want to be socially associated with. I summoned
my driver and we set off, I in the owner’s corner, and Jonszer in
the front with Sule, who received the full benefit of the unwashed
man. Beside me was Akeem, my P.A, cameraman, interpreter and general
dogsbody.
‘So tell me about this place you’re taking us to.’
‘Is a funeral. A Menai funeral.’
‘A funeral?’
‘Yes sir, a funeral.’
I sighed. This assignment was moving me closer
to anthropology than pop psychiatry. I had no interests in funerals
where I knew neither the corpse not its relatives. Yet, it was better
I was called out to too many things than too few; besides it would
be an opportunity for me to meet people, for the Menai were notoriously
quiet, at-home types. And frankly, I’d rather be doing this than
sitting at my desk at Yaba Psychiatric Hospital contesting seniority
with the likes of Dr. Malik.
‘So who died?’ I asked.
‘Nobody,’ replied Jonszer, ‘is a funeral, not a
burial. Is for Sheesti Kroma, Ruma’s daughter.’
Akeem caught my eyes and we indulged some exasperated
headshakings Nobody died! Yet, we were going to a funeral! This
is the sort of thing that happens when you are compelled to recruit
drunks as local contacts. It was like that old joke, It was a
very fatal accident, but, thank God! Nobody died. Yet, Kreektown
was only twenty or twenty-five kilometres away, and frankly, my
car was more comfortable than my hotel room (no surprise, since
the car was more expensive than the entire hotel. Which is the crazy
thing about Ubesie. This is the cultural heart of the Sontik, maybe
the third largest ethnic group in Nigeria. Sacked and burned down
by the British in the colonial wars of the late nineteenth century,
it had been resettled from 1933 onwards under Governor General Cameron,
who permitted the deposed Nanga back from exile, yet, with a local
economy more stunted than the national average, it has never quite
moved from township into city status.) So I let the driver on.
Every business in Kreektown was closed when we
arrived. There was a funeral there alright. Literally the whole
village had turned out in black robes like Jonszer’s. Never seen
that many Menai out at the same time. The centre of the event seemed
to be the village square. It was depressing and ill-lit, none of
those high-wattage bulbs that the organizers of a party, or funeral,
should have thought to provide in any civilized village. It was
like stumbling into the really Dark Ages. There was food but nobody
was eating. There were people but it wasn’t a party. There was music
– of a sort – (and it is really stretching it, to call that menacing
witchery, music, but I’m being scientific here) but no dancing.
What there was – and this they had plenty of – was this sad weeping
in song. People stood there like tree trunks and wept and sang these
haunting Menai songs, songs that made you feel wretched, like the
end of the world happened yesterday night, and they sang them one
after the other. You really don’t want to be in this square for
a real funeral. The most… sinister thing was to see the children,
some of them as small as six and seven standing and chanting like
their parents, children that in other funerals I’ve attended, would
be running around at play. It was clear that a severe order of group
psychosis was at play here. I don’t mind admitting to a most unscientific
unease.
I stayed there more than twenty minutes. Akeem
was taking photographs while we waited for something else to happen,
but nothing else happened. They just stood there and wept.
We walked through the crowd in the village square.
I recognized quite a few people that I had met in the course of
my fieldwork. They were harmless, simple folk: Mary Kana, Aida Hasnal,
that old scoundrel, Kiri Ntupong, normally the most polite and respectful
people you will find anywhere in Nigeria, but today, they waited
for me to greet them first – which I did, in the interests of scientific
enquiry – but even then… it was like speaking to people in a trance…
the wailing and the singing… it was enough to drive a fellow insane.
Then I saw the old man.
I had seen him before of course, literally the
oldest man I had ever seen. When I first arrived, I confused the
Menai by asking for their chief. They were like the Igbos used to
be, not having kings as such. Eventually they took me to this old
man who has some kind of authority over them – what exactly it was,
I still haven’t discovered. His house was rather outside the village
proper. They called him Mata, which I suppose was Menai for Master
or something. But apart from that there was nothing chiefly about
him. Had probably forgotten how to be a chief, if he ever was that.
His house was probably the poorest in the village. Doubt if it was
electrified. I mean, I won’t give, even my houseboy, that
sort of house for living quarters, oh no. I went to see him a couple
of times and all he ever did was offer me a dirty cup of water –
which of course I could not have drunk – and sit and stare at the
skies. I am not exactly a guru in old age psychiatry (I despise
the speciality) and without sticking out my neck – in the absence
of an appropriate history and all that – I’d say this was a case
of dementia: answering every official query of mine with perfect
silence.
He didn’t look very senile today. He was playing
an out-sized wooden xylophone like a man possessed. Although it
wasn’t a very energetic performance – I mean, he was playing a dirge
– still it was an immensely accomplished performance for a man of
his age. Incredibly evocative too. And even if this was not a funeral
for a dead person, in my professional opinion there was going to
be a dead old person in their midst very soon. It was almost an
entertainment on its own, watching him play, but it was also like
waiting for a fatal accident.
Eventually I turned to go. To listen to their sad
songs wasn’t a problem, I could have taken that all night, but to
be very candid there are some things that I won’t do, even for Nigeria.
To come to a funeral and stand! In the last twenty, thirty
years I can count on one hand the number of wedding, funerals or
house-warmings that I attended and wasn’t immediately invited to
sit on a high table. I mean, sometimes I’ve accompanied colleagues
to their occasions and the organizers, even without knowing
who I was, have called me up to the high table, perhaps on
account of my personality, I don‘t know. And then I attend an occasion
in a village like Kreektown and stand! Really, there’s a
limit to patriotism. To make matters worse, as soon as Jonszer arrived,
he just stepped out of the car and became a tree trunk as well.
Speaking to him was like addressing a statue. He became just another
voice under the sad metronome of the xylophone.
Yet, I got to my car, and something about the evocative
aura of that performance held me back from leaving. I am not much
of an ethnographic investigator, but the scene unfolding before
me seemed quite crucial to the construction of a psychiatric profile
of Menai. I was probably the only scientific eye ever to behold
this sight: 95% of the world population of a tribe, gathered in
one square, weeping and wailing. I could hardly leave the scene
of such scientific, linguistic and cultural significance out of
mere physical discomfort. So I compromised. I ordered Akeem to begin
a video recording of the event, which he did, bringing out the mike
from the boot, and setting up the tripod six feet from the car,
and about a dozen feet from the nearest mourners, thus enabling
me to keep a close eye on proceedings, while sitting in the comfort
of my Mercedes 500 SEL (at the time of writing, this is an 8-month-old
import and I hazard a guess that there are not 12 of its specifications
within the borders of Nigeria).
This was the point at which Jonszer turned up again.
I let down my window as he approached. His hand was out, his grin
loop-sided, with that effrontery that only drunks can muster. I
gave him a half-litre of a cheap brandy and it disappeared into
a baggy pocket. (I carry this questionable pedigree of alcohol purely
for the appeasement of area boys and rough boys) It
was difficult to know if his eyes were red from weeping or from
drinking. ‘Just come,’ he said.
‘What now?’ I asked, but he was gone, walking hurriedly,
in that demented gait of his, through the crowd and down a side
street that led off from the square. My driver had gone to ‘make
water’ (to use his charming euphemism), and Akeem was tied to his
recording. Reluctantly, I followed him alone. We did not go far,
at all; we walked down Lemue Street right up till the bend in the
road that led towards the creek, and there he stopped. He waited
in the darkness beside a car, the only one on the street. When I
joined him, he tipped his head sideways, towards a small huddle
in the doorway of the house opposite. I looked, but it was too dark
to make out faces or figures.
I was angry. It was dark. It was dusty. There was
neither CNN or BEN TV in my hotel in The Great. In my hospital,
the sly Dr. Malik was positioning himself for the office of Chief
Medical Director. My fellow consultants and contemporaries were
attending conferences and seminars in Jo’Burg and Stockholm, touring
with escorts of polyglot, lanky ladies smelling of eau de parfum.
I was walking dangerous streets with a drug addict reeking of beer
and three-month-old sweat.
‘That’s Sheesti,’ he said.
‘Who, where?’
He pointed with a jaw, and then he was gone.
I was afraid. This was precisely the point for
me to call it a night. I had to urgently return to the safety of
my car and the security of my boys – because scientific research
is best conducted with two feet solidly on the ground. Any robber
looking at my clothes just then could legitimately anticipate three
or four hundred thousand naira between my wallet and mobile phones.
I was an obvious target, but the speed of Jonszer’s withdrawal made
it impossible for me to remove myself from the area of risk without
physically taking to my heels – an undignified option which was
out of the question. I was still undecided when a man stormed out
through the huddle. He was carrying a box, and he was cursing under
his breath. The scientist in me paused, warring with the human in
me, which urgently desired the owners’ corner of my Mercedes Benz.
‘Are you okay?’ I asked, as the man flung the box into the boot
of the car.
‘I am a detribalized Nigerian!’ he shouted, seemingly,
addressing not just all of Lemue Street, but the entire Kreektown
itself, ‘My father is Yoruba, my mother is Ibibio…’
‘Calm down,’ I told him.
He only shouted louder, ‘My hospital is in Onitsha!
I have lived in Kano! In Calabar! in Lagos!’
‘Just like me,’ I told him, but he had slammed
the boot shut and stormed back into the house.
I was free again to go, but by now the human in
me was even more curious than the scientist. I approached the house,
whose number I now saw was 43. The huddle resolved into two women.
The younger was weeping, begging the older, who was going, ‘there’s
nothing I can do now, there’s nothing I can do.’
I clasped my fingers over the gentle rise of my
stomach and, using a voice developed over thirty-five years of clinical
medicine, I asked, ‘Are you quite alright? I am Chief Dr. Ehi Alela
Fowaka, JP, is there anything at all I can do to help?’
I got the polite response I have worked so hard
to get, anywhere I go in this great country. They greeted me, the
younger one curtseying, but before they could speak further, ‘I-am-a-Detribalized-Nigerian’
stormed past, fuming, ‘You are all wizards and witches! I’m sorry!
Wizards and witches, that’s what you are!’
‘Easy, Denle, this is…’ began the younger woman,
but the man was having none of it. He had a half-packed bag in his
hand and with the other hand he grabbed the woman’s arm and pulled
her towards the car.
‘Let’s go, Sheesti, before they actually kill you.
Wizards!’
‘Is because we love you…’ began the older, but
two doors slammed shut and one very angry BMW pulled away in a scream
of tyres.
I was standing before the older woman when suddenly
I recognized the transcendental moment of the entire research project.
A river of wisdom and calm understanding flowed through me, and
I understood how the gurus of the fallen religions of the world
can become seduced into the delusion of godship. I deduced the elaborate
social mechanism used by this atavistic society to corral her sad,
individuals into communal compliance. ‘You must be Sheesti’s mother,’
I said gently.
She nodded.
‘She looks quite well to me, why would you hold
her funeral?’
She opened her hands. ‘It has nothing to do with
me. It is custom, it is alright for her to marry a foreigner – we
encourage our daughters to marry foreigners, but they must
come and live in Kreektown, that is our custom.’
‘Otherwise you apply the emotional blackmail of
a symbolic funeral?’ I shook my head gently, as non-judgmentally
as it is possible to be, without partaking in stupidity, ‘This is
1994 you know, not 1794. We have laws, federal laws… And
what does your husband have to say about this?’
‘Nothing.’
‘You don’t mind if I have a word with him? Is he
in the square, partaking of this... ah... custom?’
‘He’s inside, but…’
‘Oh, don’t worry,’ I smiled. This is one thing
that thirty-five years of senior medical practice gives you, the
ability to say grave and serious things with a smile. People are
used to getting bad news from doctors. Anyone else gives the news
and they go to pieces, or go ballistic, but a doctor – with the
experience – breaks it, and you see the difference. I pushed past
the woman – now, this is not something I would normally do, pushing
myself so precipitately into private affairs, but… the things one
does for nation… I stood in the middle of a largish living room
– desperately poor of course by my standards, but in the context
of Kreektown, quite middleclassy, really. There was a colour television,
a fancy sofa and most bizarrely a chest freezer; and in the middle
of all that sat a sad-looking man in a wheelchair. ‘Good evening,
sir.’ I began.
He just leered at me. I began to vex. I normally
would not have given him a ‘sir’ but for the wheelchair… ‘He hasn’t
said a word since his stroke in 1989,’ she said, from very close
behind me. Munificent God! This guru thing is quite exhausting.
She continued without a break, ‘he has nothing to do with this,
it is custom. He himself is an Igarra man. We married in February,
1963 and he moved here in the April of that very same year. Since
then he has only visited Igarra maybe five or six times before his
stroke. Is what I told Sheesti… Is it cold enough?’
I touched the bottle of wine she had produced for
my inspection from the chest. There was a strong smell of goat meat
from the exterior of the bottle.
‘It’s very nice, thank you.’
She opened it and poured me a glass, talking all
the while, as her physical proximity forced me backwards and heavily
onto her sofa ‘Is what I told Sheesti, I told her, marry him and
bring him here, like me and your daddy did, but no…’ and she went
on and on.
I sat there sipping the wine, ignoring the smell
of meat, and trying hard not to stare at Sheesti’s father in the
chair. Ruma was clearly woman’s woman; her English was clearly as
fluent as her Menai and her sentences flowed steadily, brooking
no interruption. She manifested the Menai custom of aggressive hospitality,
which I was prepared to indulge in this case, since her offering
was a sealed, if pathetically cheap, bottle of wine. (A few weeks
earlier I was forced to reject an unhygienic offering of locally
brewed gin invested with an eye-watering reek, and observed the
subsequent hostility and animosity which forced my visit to end
rather more precipitately than I planned.)
The eyes of Sheesti’s father seemed quite alive,
despite the long dribble that led down from rubbery lips to a wet
shirt. I couldn’t pull my eyes away from this Igarra man who could
not attend the funeral of his Menai daughter who was not yet dead.
Yet, I was a scientist with a job to do. I turned to his wife, feeling
the Igarra eyes burning paralysing lasers into the side of my head
‘Who is behind this thing?’ I asked, firmly, cutting off her chatter,
‘who organized this funeral?’
‘Excuse me,’ she said, and disappeared into the
house, apparently to produce some documentary evidence. This was
the good thing about dealing with people of a better quality than
the Jonszers of this world. Documentary evidence would go down very
well on a presidential report. In the meantime I was forced to return
to the scrutiny of the ‘master’ of the house. I wondered whether
to attempt a one-sided conversation in which I would supply commentaries,
questions and suggested answers. This is usually not a problem for
me. With my thirty-five years’ experience, armed with a treatment
chart, I can hold a ten-minute ward-round conversation with a comatose
patient, particularly with a dozen student doctors and nurses clustered
around me, trying to pick up useful hints for their viva exams.
But there was something about that Kreektown parlour that threw
me off my stride. This did not seem the proper forum to review the
pessimistic prognoses of cerebro-vascular accidents.
Then she returned. She did not have any facts,
figures or documentary evidence, but she had painted her face, and
although she still looked like my mother’s marginally younger sister,
she no longer looked like the mother of a woman whose funeral dirge
we could hear from the street. Then she came and sat next to me
on the sofa, close enough for me to perceive a rather rancid variation
on the eau de parfum theme. ‘As you were saying,’ she said,
and there was something else in her voice, which was when I looked
at the sadness in the eyes of the Igarra man and realized that,
president or no president, this fieldwork was ending right there,
right then.
‘By the way,’ I asked kindly, ‘what's your name?’
‘Ruma,’ she simpered,
‘Ruma,’ I said, ‘good night.’
I left for my hotel.
|
|
|
|
|